新加坡:8成人住組屋好幸福? 移民5年港人:「新加坡人做豬,都是快樂的豬」

125次觀看 8/14/2020
0 0 保存 舉報
  • 加入稍后观看
X
  • 請登錄后使用
X
  • 反饋成功
AD
+ 展開 - 收縮
接下來播放
用戶評論
  • Eleven 11

    你找错人访问了,这女的给了几个错的信息误导他人。政府组屋是99年leasehold,私人房子有99年leashold,也有永久的freehold。无论那一种房子,只要付清银行贷款,你都会有屋契。私人99年住久了,就期待有发展商收购。政府组屋旧了,就等政府整栋翻新,分派你到新的组屋,给你优惠价购买。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • blurblobs88

    製作人找了這位不知所謂的新加坡人,完全反應了製作人的不認真。。。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Food Lover

    只有离开新加坡后才会知道新加坡的好。那些一天到晚只会complain的新加坡人去到哪里还是会complain的。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • sin cere

    政治問題衍生民生問題~ 不要本末倒置。當一個城市裏的醫生、律師、博士生都走上街頭,難道會只是因為買不起房子嗎?

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Thomas Wan

    做新加坡人 已經幸福過做香港人十萬倍 因為 新加坡的士國理念 房屋解決問題 和民生方面 好過香港嘅垃圾政府管治多多聲

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Saber

    其實新加坡移民門檻好高 去得新加坡, 其實都去到其他地方

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Alfred Ang

    访问一个草莓族而且是个没有上进心的。 她对本地社会也不了解就批评。 根本没见过世界。 如果要走请快一点。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Darren Lee

    请了一个无脑的小朋友做访问,不懂装懂,错误百出,误导大众!应该找个有房有社会经验的人把?想离开到外地生活?小朋友,你还不知道很多发达国家的日常开销是这里的两倍以上!还不包括买房!

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Carol Toh

    是的, 找錯人訪問, 這個女的很多東西都不了解

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Francis Wong

    There are quite a few inaccurancies in the interview. 1. For single Singaporeans above 35, they can buy a studio apartment from HDB. It costs less than SGD150K. 10% downpayment (SGS15K). The area is about 45 m2 (actual usable area). Income ceiling for single is SGD6000/month. As she said if she is single below 35, she is only allowed to buy private properties. A similar size private property costs around SGD600-800K(99 year leasehold). The downpaymern is 5% cash (SGD30-40K) and 15% CPF(SGD 90-120K). The downpayment is much more. That's her choice to wait till 35 or come out with close to SDG150K to buy a private property now. 2. The private housing is not intended to be the mass market. The mass market remains to be HDB. The private housing market was originally meant for rich Singaporeans and foreigners. It is only 20% of the housing market whereas in HK the private properties is more than 60% of the housing market. Hence the pressure of getting a house in HK young people is much higher. 3. Most of the new private properties now is 99 year leasehold. There are still some with 999 year leasehold or freehold but the price is much higher. 4. For the problems of 99 year leasehold of HDB, it is a real concern of most Singaporeans. There are some proposals such as extending the lease by topping up some money or selective redevelopment. It will be a challenge for the government to come up with a workable solution. 5. Most young Singaporeans around the girl's age stay with parents. I do not see why she was kind of complaining staying with parents. She can move out until she qualifies to buy a 2-room studio apartment from the government or buy a bigger resale 3 rooms in the open market.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • KL Poon

    I doubt this Singaporean lady's view is representative of her generation.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Tan SH

    Of all the people, they have to find a stupid girl

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Wang Poh Peng

    I have to say, the interviewee selected for the Singaporean side is a poorly selected one. You do not dismiss a country's culture based on your experiences when you fail to explore and discover the land's history and way of life. Pretty disappointed with her words and this video is highly inaccurate of what people feel about public housing.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • LIU KHEE FANG

    这位受访女士对新加坡组屋概念不了解,加上个人历练有限,她的视野与人生观点就受到局限。不否定持有这些观点的大有人在,但不是大多数人的看法。此视频制作者以滥竽充数的心态制作此片,其意图是昭然若揭。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Carol Toh

    太隨便了,與 事實有些不對, 這個女的對自己的國家有很多不懂的地方

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Clement Gome

    雖然新加坡沒有幾百年,幾千年留下來的歷史 但現在的新加坡比起很多國家好很多。 我也會想去國外居住但我還是不會放棄新加坡公民。最多只是去國外住住,感受一下不同的人事物。新加坡還是我的家。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • IMHO

    訪問的星加坡女士其實不太懂。私人房屋也99年地契的。還有、如果兩夫妻都是永久居民、也可以在公開市場買已五年或以上的組屋。全新組屋才需要有至少一個新加坡人的夫妻。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • canberra2011

    什么话,斗不过政府,你究竟要斗什么?真是生在福中不知福。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • learn

    你說的不对,一般60年的组屋政府会帮我们翻新后会增值,我还没退休,屋子的代款已还完。退休后我的公积金政府还给我6%的利息,那位小姐勤奋些节俭些,别赚了就花,也別一直在那怨天忧人。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • yvonne yeo

    只知道花和赚,一点储蓄也没,和来钱买房,人家所讲的还没学走就要飞高,她自己讲的,这个国家有她没她没差,那请走好。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Fun Wong

    IF Singapore is where you want to be, you will still need to meet the cut to make it through the door. :) Relocating is never easy...wherever that may be. Need to embrace the new culture and way of life...otherwise, happiness is just an ideal...you will never be happy anywhere.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Angus Lee

    Just one example, But she didn’t know how good her life is

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Fausto Nissi

    Singapore is a peaceful city Singapore have health culture . Singapore and Hong Kong is totally different culture and thinking different . Singapore changi Airport international cityscape is beautiful . Is bad to mentioned Singaporean is rubbish comment perhaps they jealous Singaporean.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • An Photosiew

    连我这个马来西亚人都看不过去这样采访记录片。简直就像有点断章取义那样。新加坡不像香港那样政府政策利益跑头民生问题抛后。虽然和新加坡一样都是金融中心。但民生问题却比新加坡多。采访了为什么不总结自己的看法。总结我赖帮你说吧!香港只是表面繁华内在贫穷。。民生问题一大堆。利益跑头的政府。采访一个没有脑的女孩。可能她自己都不知道新加坡那一年独立的。

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • 楊斌

    資料不全 單身可以買二手樓 三十五歲買政府樓 屋滿99年 政府收回會以市價賠 同樣可以購買祖屋 條女都冇做功課,她說選擇離開,我敢說她除了去印尼在大馬也買不到房屋

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • LIM

    其实每个国家都有每个国家的问题,个人觉得自己生长的国家最好,那份归属感是没有办法在别的地方感受得到的。香港现在是乱,很多人都想移民,但请香港人三思,没有一个国家完美,香港也不会一直这样下去,可能有一天会好起来。香港加油

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Coffeebud Hong

    The woman gave all the wrong info to the public, bad image for Singapore govt

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Frank Jin

    中国大陆,那个。。。100年都没有,土地是政府借给你们用70年的。 现在虽然说70年后自动续期,但是那都是坊间谣言 共产党真要拆, 你屁都不敢放 尤其是现在共产党武力强大, 老百姓连告洋状的地方都没有了

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • SW Wong

    This is totally not objective. Poor documentary.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Kelvin Lin

    Let's hope this girl get to migrate to other countries since she don't feel a sense of belonging.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • 楊懋

    这部片子的出发点就不对,所以内容不知所谓,片面之词。完全不是真实的

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • derrickg91

    interviewed a typical strawberry generation. Immature, childish, only know shopping.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Chee Wei Yong

    The information the interviewee provided is totally incorrect. Assuming you and your bf want to buy a HDB, if both of you have total 4k monthly income, and contributed CPF 5 years. Both of you should have roughly 40~50k in CPF, and you are totally able to afford a 300k HDB, which only need to pay 10%, 30k down payment, and the monthly installment of 1k can pay by the CPF monthly contribution. And if you are a *normal people* like most of the Singaporean, your monthly income should fall within 3k for 20s, and 4k for 30s per person. So you can aim for 400-500k property, or even take some risks to look for 600-700k. Lastly, the phase 「新加坡人做豬,都是快樂的豬」..... IS ........ SUPER ........INSULTING............

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • R T

    一百年前,五四運動的先烈是為了有房子才搞革命嗎?

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Morrighan Mariota

    係香港20年唔食唔飲買車位就差唔到.況且香港好多人人工都係萬幾蚊

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Eng Hoe Wee

    I think the producer look for this young lady reflect that the producer and the interviewer totally does not understand Singapore at all

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • 忘憂

    最后那句説对了!真的是有無妳也没差。賺錢花錢没听到存錢!

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • vhoung Ng

    Huh, this is whole new level of reporting, LOW. The girl seriously need some soul searching. By the way, 黑衣廢青don't come. Ops, they can't afford anyway.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Yu Frank Lim

    Warren's theory represents the root of man kind, you are very intelligent. GOOD MAN.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Dennis Woo

    The price in Singapore can pay 3 houses of same size in Malaysia. Food in Malaysia is only 1/3 from Singapore.

    + 展開 - 收縮
  • Jazz Li

    The Chinese tradition you must have a house then you can get marry

    + 展開 - 收縮

免責聲明:

本網站是以實時上傳文章的方式運作,本站對所有文章的真實性、完整性及立場等,不負任何法律責任。 而一切文章內容只代表發文者個人意見,並非本網站之立場,用戶不應信賴內容,並應自行判斷內容之真實性。發文者擁有在本站張貼的文章。

由於本站是受到「實時發表」運作方式所規限,故不能完全監查所有即時文章,若讀者發現有留言出現問題,請聯絡我們。

本站有權刪除任何內容及拒絕任何人士發文,同時亦有不刪除文章的權力。切勿撰寫粗言穢語、毀謗、渲染色情暴力或人身攻擊的言論,敬請自律。本網站保留一切法律權利。